Pit Boss and Traeger are two of the biggest names in pellet grills, but choosing between them is no longer as simple as paying more for a Traeger to get better temperature control and more features.
I’ve cooked extensively on pellet smokers from both brands. Although neither is my personal favorite across the entire pellet grill market, I’ve generally enjoyed using the Pit Boss models more than the Traegers I’ve tested. Pit Boss also tends to give you more cooking space and better grilling ability for your money.
Traeger still has advantages. Its WiFIRE app, cleanup systems and overall presentation tend to feel more polished. The premium Woodridge Elite even adds a dedicated electric side searing station. But after using the Ironwood XL—which was extremely slow to heat, not particularly steady and badly affected by strong wind—I would not assume that paying more for a Traeger guarantees better cooking performance.
Here’s how Pit Boss and Traeger compare today, including the current models I would actually consider from each brand.
Burning Brisket is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read our affiliate policy to learn more.
Quick Verdict
Both Pit Boss and Traeger make pellet grills that can cook great BBQ. The real difference is whether you want more cooking space and grilling versatility for your money, or a more polished app and ownership experience.
Choose Pit Boss if:
- You want more cooking space for the price
- You want direct-flame grilling as well as low-and-slow smoking
- You want WiFi and modern controls without paying Traeger prices
- You care more about versatility and value than premium finish
Choose Traeger if:
- You want a more refined, polished user experience
- You value Traeger’s WiFIRE app and accessory ecosystem
- You prefer easier grease and ash cleanup
- You’re happy paying more for convenience rather than extra capacity
Quick Picks: Best Pit Boss & Traeger Smokers
To make this easier, these are the Pit Boss and Traeger models I’d actually choose from based on current value, features, and how they fit different buyers.
🥇 Best Pit Boss Overall
IF YOU WANT: The best all-round Pit Boss for most families, with WiFi, plenty of space, and better grilling versatility than a Traeger.
💰 Best Affordable Pit Boss
IF YOU WANT: A full-sized pellet grill with a large hopper, plenty of space and direct-flame searing without paying for WiFi.
🥩 Best for Large Families
IF YOU WANT: Maximum cooking space for bigger cooks, parties, and family gatherings without paying premium Traeger prices.
📱 Best Traeger Overall
IF YOU WANT: A current-generation Traeger with easier cleanup, a polished app experience, and a simple everyday setup.
💵 Best Lower-Priced Traeger
IF YOU WANT: A more affordable way into the Traeger lineup with WiFIRE control and a solid all-round pellet smoking setup.
⚙️ Best Traeger for Features
IF YOU WANT: Traeger’s full feature set, including Super Smoke, easier cleanup, insulated construction and a dedicated side sear station.
If you’re still deciding whether pellet grills are right for you, check out pellet vs electric smokers and pellet vs offset smokers to see how these compare to other options.
Table of Contents
Pit Boss vs Traeger: Quick Comparison
| Feature | Pit Boss | Traeger |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Value, capacity and direct-flame grilling | App control, easier cleanup and premium convenience |
| Price | Generally lower | Generally higher |
| Build and finish | Solid but more utilitarian | Usually more polished and integrated |
| Temperature control | Good on current models; varies by individual grill | Good on current models; also varies by individual grill |
| Smoke flavor | Mild pellet smoke | Mild pellet smoke; Super Smoke on selected models |
| Ease of use | Straightforward, but often messier to clean | Generally cleaner and more refined |
| Cooking capacity | Usually more space for the money | Often less capacity at a similar price |
| Direct-flame grilling | Available on many models | Not available inside the main cooking chamber |
| Separate searing station | Usually unnecessary because of the Flame Broiler | Available on the Woodridge Elite |
| WiFi | Available on connected ranges | Available across most current mainstream models |
| App experience | Useful but less polished | WiFIRE is more established |
| Warranty | Commonly five years on mainstream pellet grills | Varies by model and series |
| Overall value | Better for most buyers | You pay more for polish and convenience |
Pit Boss Overview
Pit Boss focuses on giving you more grill for your money. Across its current range, that usually means larger cooking areas, practical hopper sizes and direct-flame grilling without pushing prices as high as Traeger.
I used an older Pit Boss Navigator for several years and generally liked cooking on it. It made good food, handled both smoking and grilling, and felt like a lot of smoker for the price. The Flame Broiler was straightforward to use and worked well for grilling a few burgers or steaks, although the direct-heat area was fairly limited. Read more about my Pit Boss Navigator experience here.
The current range is more advanced than the models I first used, with WiFi and Bluetooth now available on connected Navigators and larger options for families and group cooking.
Pit Boss still feels more practical than polished, but that is also where much of its value comes from.
Traeger Overview
Traeger is the original pellet grill brand and still positions itself as the more polished option. Its current range runs from older-style Pro Series grills through the newer Woodridge models and up to premium Ironwood and Timberline smokers.
I have cooked on several Traegers, including the Ironwood XL. It looked and felt premium, but the actual cooking experience did not justify the price for me. It took a long time to heat, was not especially steady, ran cooler than expected and was noticeably affected by strong wind.
Traeger’s strengths are its WiFIRE app, cleaner grease and ash management and more integrated premium features. Higher-end models also add options such as Super Smoke, insulation, enclosed storage and, on the Woodridge Elite, a separate side searing station.
The range feels more refined overall, but I would not assume that refinement automatically means better temperature control or better food.
Key Differences Between Pit Boss and Traeger
Temperature Control
There is no clear brand-wide winner here anymore.
Older Pit Boss pellet grills were more likely to use basic controllers and show wider temperature swings. That used to be one of Traeger’s stronger advantages, but the current Pit Boss range has narrowed the gap considerably.
The latest connected Navigator models now offer WiFi, Bluetooth and much finer temperature adjustments. Current Traegers also use advanced digital controllers, but that does not mean they always hold a steadier cooking temperature.
With the Traeger Ironwood XL, I found it:
- took a very long time to reach temperature
- did not hold heat as steadily as I expected
- often seemed to run cooler than the displayed setting
- became noticeably worse in strong wind
I have also used Pit Boss grills that fluctuated, particularly older models, but the difference between these brands is now much more model-specific.
Both can maintain a workable smoking temperature. I would not pay more for a Traeger purely because you expect tighter control.
Cooking Speed & Heat Performance
My biggest frustration with the Ironwood XL was how slow it felt.
It took a long time to preheat, and increasing the temperature for hotter cooking was not quick either. Because the grill sometimes seemed to be running cooler around the food than the controller suggested, cooks could also take longer than expected.
That matters when you are using a pellet grill for convenience. You do not want to turn it on for a weeknight dinner and spend an excessive amount of time waiting for it to become usable.
Pit Boss heat-up time still varies by model. A large Navigator 1300 has a sizeable cooking chamber to warm, so I would not assume every Pit Boss is fast.
The important point is that Traeger’s higher price does not automatically buy faster heating or more predictable cooking times.
Smoke Output & Quality
Both brands produce the relatively clean, mild smoke typical of pellet grills.
You can get good bark, a visible smoke ring and clear wood-fired flavor from either. But neither usually produces the stronger smoke profile you would expect from charcoal or an offset smoker.
Selected Traegers, including the Woodridge Elite, include Super Smoke. This increases smoke production during lower-temperature cooking and gives you more control over how smoky you want the food.
Pit Boss does not offer the same branded smoke mode across its range. Some models naturally move through wider heating cycles, which can create periods of heavier smoke as pellets smolder.
In real cooking, I would not expect a dramatic flavor difference between comparable Pit Boss and Traeger models. The pellets, cooking temperature and amount of time the food spends in the smoke matter just as much.
Build Quality and Design
Traeger generally feels more polished.
Its newer grills tend to have cleaner controller integration, better-organized storage and more refined grease and ash management. The Woodridge Elite, with its enclosed cabinet and side cooking station, looks and functions more like a complete outdoor kitchen unit.
Pit Boss is more utilitarian.
You usually get a large steel cooking chamber, useful shelves and plenty of grate space without the same level of finish. That does not mean Pit Boss grills feel flimsy. They simply put more of the price into size and cooking hardware.
I would not assume the more expensive Traeger will automatically last longer, either. The Ironwood XL I used began showing rust much earlier than I expected from a premium pellet smoker.
Traeger has the more polished design. Pit Boss generally gives you more physical grill for the money.
Ease of Use
Both brands are easy to cook on.
Fill the hopper, set the temperature and let the grill manage the pellet feed and airflow. You do not need to build a fire or make regular vent adjustments during a long cook.
Traeger has the edge in the parts of ownership that happen around the cook.
The WiFIRE app is well established, and the newer Woodridge models use a more integrated grease and ash collection system. That makes routine cleanup simpler than dismantling a traditional pellet grill and vacuuming ash from around the firepot.
Pit Boss’s connected models also give you remote control and monitoring. The experience is more functional than premium, but it covers the main things most people need.
The Pit Boss Flame Broiler was straightforward to use when I owned a Navigator. Its real limitation was not mess or difficulty. It was the size of the direct-heat zone, which is suitable for a few burgers or steaks rather than grilling across the entire grate.
Traeger offers a slightly smoother ownership experience, but both are simple enough for a beginner.
Grilling and Searing
This is one of the most meaningful differences between the brands.
Pit Boss Flame Broiler
Many Pit Boss grills allow you to slide open the heat diffuser directly above the pellet fire.
That exposes part of the cooking grate to direct flame and creates a genuine high-heat zone. I liked using it for burgers and steaks because it felt much closer to cooking on a normal grill than relying on indirect heat alone.
The limitation is space.
The firepot sits in the center of the smoker, so the true searing area is fairly small. It works well for a few burgers or steaks, but it does not turn the whole cooking surface into an open-flame grill.
Even so, it gives Pit Boss much better grilling ability than a standard Traeger.
Standard Traeger Grilling
Most Traeger pellet grills keep the food separated from the fire by a solid heat diffuser and drip tray.
You can increase the temperature and cook burgers, chicken or sausages, but you are still cooking over indirect heat. It works, but it does not give you the same concentrated heat or flame contact as Pit Boss.
Woodridge Elite Side Searing Station
The Woodridge Elite gives Traeger a much better answer.
Its separate electric side station lets you sear steaks, cook in a pan or sauté vegetables while the main pellet chamber continues smoking at a lower temperature.
That is particularly useful for reverse searing. You can smoke steaks gently, then move them straight onto the side station without waiting for the whole pellet grill to heat up.
It is a different setup from Pit Boss.
Pit Boss gives you direct heat from the wood-pellet fire inside the main chamber. The Woodridge Elite gives you a separate electric cooking surface.
The Traeger station is easier to control and does not interrupt the food still cooking inside the smoker. But it is only available on a much more expensive model.
Pit Boss offers the better grilling value. The Woodridge Elite offers the most complete and convenient Traeger grilling setup.
For more grills designed around higher heat, see my guide to the best pellet smokers for grilling.
WiFi, Apps and Extra Features
WiFi is no longer a simple reason to choose Traeger.
Current Pit Boss Navigator models offer WiFi and Bluetooth, while the more affordable FB2 range leaves connectivity out to keep the price down.
Traeger still has the more mature app ecosystem.
WiFIRE supports remote temperature changes, timers, meat-probe monitoring and recipe guidance across much of the range. The app feels more integrated into the overall Traeger ownership experience.
As you move higher through Traeger’s range, you can also get:
- Super Smoke
- easier grease and ash collection
- insulated lids or cooking chambers
- enclosed storage
- pellet monitoring
- accessory rails
- the Woodridge Elite side searing station
Pit Boss puts more emphasis on cooking space, direct flame, large hoppers and lower prices.
The choice is less about smart versus basic than it used to be.
Pit Boss gives you more cooking hardware for the money. Traeger gives you more refined software and convenience features.
Performance in Bad Weather
Neither brand has been consistently impressive for me in exposed conditions.
An older Pit Boss Navigator I used allowed wind and rain through its rear vents during particularly rough weather.
The Traeger Ironwood XL was also badly affected by strong wind. It already took a long time to heat, and exposed conditions made that worse.
That makes me cautious about recommending either brand purely for weather performance.
Traeger does offer more insulation on selected premium models, which should reduce heat loss during cold-weather cooking. But insulation does not completely solve problems caused by airflow through the grill’s vents.
Whichever brand you choose, positioning matters. A sheltered location can make a bigger difference than the logo on the lid, provided the grill still has the ventilation and clearances required by the manufacturer.
See my guide to the best pellet grills for cold weather for models better suited to exposed or colder conditions.
Hopper Capacity
Hopper size is one of the reasons I would feature the Pit Boss 850 FB2 rather than the cheaper 500 FB2.
The 500 FB2 has a five-pound hopper. That is enough for shorter cooks, but it is small for a full-sized pellet smoker and could require topping up during a brisket or pork shoulder.
That compromises one of the main benefits of buying a pellet grill: loading it with fuel and letting it run with minimal attention.
The 850 FB2 has a much more practical 21-pound hopper. That makes it better suited to overnight and all-day cooks.
The Navigator 850 and 1300 also have large hoppers, while the Traeger Pro 780 and Woodridge models are designed around normal long-cook use.
The 500 FB2 may be cheaper, but the 850 FB2 is the more sensible recommendation for someone buying a pellet smoker as their main backyard cooker.
Value for Money
Pit Boss is still the stronger value brand overall.
You usually get:
- more cooking space
- larger hoppers
- direct-flame grilling
- useful shelves and prep space
- connected models at lower prices
- fewer premiums for branding and finish
The Pit Boss 850 FB2 is a good example. It gives you a full-sized cooking chamber, a 21-pound hopper and direct-flame grilling without making you pay for app connectivity.
The Traeger Pro 780 can sometimes sit surprisingly close to it in price, particularly when discounted.
That creates a genuine decision:
- Choose the Pit Boss 850 FB2 for direct flame and the larger hopper.
- Choose the Traeger Pro 780 for WiFIRE and Traeger’s more established app.
Once you move into the current Woodridge range, Traeger becomes substantially more expensive.
The Woodridge Elite offers features Pit Boss cannot match in the same polished package, particularly its separate electric side station and enclosed storage. But it is a premium purchase, not the economical route to smoking and searing.
Pit Boss makes more sense for most buyers. Traeger makes more sense when the software, cleanup and premium features are genuinely worth paying for.
Warranty
Pit Boss commonly offers five years on its mainstream pellet grills.
Traeger warranty periods vary more by model and generation, with some newer premium models carrying longer coverage than older grills.
It is better to compare the exact products than assume one warranty applies across either brand’s entire range.
Check which parts are covered, how long electronics are included and whether rust, cosmetic damage, shipping or commercial use are excluded.
Pit Boss vs Traeger Models Compared
Here is what your money gets from the six models I would consider.
| Model | Cooking Area | Hopper | Connectivity | High-Heat Option | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pit Boss 850 FB2 | Approx. 850 sq. in. | 21 lb. | No | Flame Broiler | Affordable full-sized smoking and grilling |
| Pit Boss Navigator 850 Connected | Approx. 930 sq. in. | 30 lb. | WiFi + Bluetooth | Flame Broiler | Most families |
| Pit Boss Navigator 1300 Connected | Approx. 1,330 sq. in. | 30 lb. | WiFi + Bluetooth | Flame Broiler | Large cooks and groups |
| Traeger Pro 780 | 780 sq. in. | Approx. 18–19 lb. | WiFIRE | Indirect grilling | Value-priced Traeger |
| Traeger Woodridge | 860 sq. in. | Full-sized hopper | WiFIRE | Indirect grilling | Everyday convenience |
| Traeger Woodridge Elite | 970 sq. in. | Full-sized hopper | WiFIRE | Electric side station | Premium features and versatile cooking |
Pit Boss vs Traeger: Which Should You Choose?
Choose Pit Boss if:
- You want more cooking space for your money.
- You want flame grilling.
- You need a practical hopper for long cooks.
- You want connected options without premium pricing.
- You value versatility more than polish.
Skip Pit Boss if:
- You want the easiest grease and ash cleanup.
- You want the most polished app.
- You prefer an enclosed, integrated design.
- You want a separate searing surface.
- You mostly smoke and do not need direct flame.
Choose Traeger if:
- You want the more established WiFIRE app.
- You prefer a refined ownership experience.
- You're after stronger smoke flavor with Super Smoke mode.
- You want the Woodridge Elite side station.
Skip Traeger if:
- You expect the higher price to guarantee steadier temperatures.
- You want direct access to the pellet flame.
- You want the most capacity for your budget.
- You do not care about app features.
Want to See How These Brands Compare to Others?
Pit Boss and Traeger are not your only options.
My best pellet smokers guide compares the strongest current choices across several brands.
For more affordable models, see the best pellet grills under $500.
You can also read my Z Grills vs Traeger comparison for the option of another brand I really love.
Final Verdict: Is Pit Boss or Traeger Better?
Pit Boss is the better buy for most people.
You generally get more cooking space, practical hopper sizes and direct-flame grilling for less money. The 850 FB2 is the stronger affordable option, while the Navigator 850 Connected is the better all-round choice if you also want WiFi and Bluetooth.
Traeger still has advantages. Its app, cleanup system and overall design feel more polished, and the Woodridge Elite adds a genuinely useful side searing station.
But I would not pay more for a Traeger expecting faster heat-up or steadier temperatures. My Ironwood XL was slow to heat, inconsistent and badly affected by wind.
Choose Pit Boss for value, capacity and grilling versatility.
Choose Traeger for polish, easier ownership and premium convenience.
FAQ
Is Pit Boss Better Than Traeger?
Pit Boss is better for buyers who want more cooking space, direct-flame grilling and stronger value.
Traeger is better if you prioritize WiFIRE, easier cleanup, integrated design and premium features such as the Woodridge Elite side station.
Does Pit Boss Hold Temperature as Well as Traeger?
Current models from both brands can maintain workable low-and-slow temperatures.
Neither brand is consistently steadier across every model.
Performance depends on the controller, cooking-chamber design, weather, pellet condition, maintenance and sensor position.
Is the Pit Boss 850 FB2 Better Than the Traeger Pro 780?
Choose the Pit Boss 850 FB2 for direct-flame grilling and its larger hopper.
Choose the Traeger Pro 780 for WiFIRE and Traeger’s more established app.
When their prices are close, the better choice depends on which of those features matters more.
Is Pit Boss Better for Grilling?
Pit Boss offers better grilling value because many of its pellet grills provide direct-flame access.
The high-heat area is limited to the section above the firepot, but it works well for a few burgers or steaks.
The Woodridge Elite offers a more premium alternative with its separate electric side station.
Can You Sear on the Traeger Woodridge Elite?
Yes.
The Woodridge Elite has a separate electric side cooking station that can be used for searing, sautéing and pan cooking.
It lets you keep the pellet chamber at a lower smoking temperature while finishing food at high heat.
Which Brand Is Better for Beginners?
Both are easy enough for beginners.
Pit Boss gives you better value and more grilling versatility.
Traeger gives you a more polished app and easier cleanup.
The better choice depends on whether you care more about cooking flexibility or the smoothest ownership experience.
Is Traeger Worth the Extra Money?
It can be when you value its app, easier cleaning and premium features.
The Woodridge Elite side station is particularly useful for someone who wants a pellet smoker and a convenient high-heat cooking surface in one setup.
It is less worthwhile if you mainly want straightforward low-and-slow smoking or are happy using Pit Boss’s more affordable direct-flame system.
Kate Brown is the founder of Burning Brisket, where she shares hands-on smoker reviews, barbecue gear guides, and practical tips for backyard BBQ. She has cooked extensively on charcoal, pellet, electric, and kamado smokers, using real-world experience to help beginners choose the right equipment and make better barbecue at home. Her focus is honest, straightforward advice that makes smoking and grilling easier without unnecessary complexity.
